TheUtilityCalc
⚖️ Metro Utility Cost Comparison • 2026 Fiscal Records

Brookings, SD vs New York City, NY

Relocating or comparing cost of living? Here is the complete head-to-head utility bill breakdown between Brookings and New York City, based on public utility commission filings and municipal meter schedules.

South Dakota View Calculator →

Brookings

Brookings County • Pop. 60,000

Average Bill: $293/mo
Cost Variance
-$147/mo
Annual Difference: $1,766/yr

Brookings is approximately 33% cheaper than New York City in overall monthly utility bills.

New York View Calculator →

New York City

New York County (Manhattan) • Pop. 8,335,817

Average Bill: $440/mo
🤖

Executive Summary & Citability Passage

EIA / NOAA / Municipal Survey 2026

In 2026, living in Brookings, SD incurs an average monthly utility expense of $293, compared to $440 per month in New York City, NY. This reflects a 33% lower overall household utility cost, saving homeowners approximately $147 monthly or $1,766 each calendar year. Residential power tariffs in Brookings average $0.124 per kWh supplied by Xcel Energy / Black Hills Energy, whereas New York City residents pay $0.265 per kWh through Consolidated Edison (ConEd). Municipal water and sewer charges also diverge, with Brookings averaging $36.00 in combined monthly meter baselines versus $37.50 in New York City. Climatologically, Brookings registers 1295 Cooling Degree Days and 5446 Heating Degree Days, compared to 1180 CDD and 4750 HDD in New York City, creating distinctly different seasonal heating and cooling load patterns across winter and summer quarters. Overall, verified 2026 public tariff benchmarks confirm that Brookings maintains more economical municipal utility infrastructure than New York City.

Interactive Simulation

Household Sizing Simulator

Select your home type to adjust estimated monthly consumption for Brookings and New York City.

Brookings Est.
$293/mo
Power:$123
Water & Sewer:$89
Gas & Trash:$87
Projected Variance
-$147/mo

Brookings saves your household roughly $1,766 per year at this consumption tier.

New York City Est.
$440/mo
Power:$258
Water & Sewer:$107
Gas & Trash:$102

Head-to-Head Utility Tariff Breakdown

Direct comparison of published rates, electric tariffs, and municipal meter charges.

EIA-861 Calibrated
Utility Component Brookings, SD New York City, NY
⚡ Residential Electric Rate ($/kWh) $0.124 / kWh $0.265 / kWh
Electric Monthly Customer Base Fee $11.00/mo $19.50/mo
Electric Provider & Market Structure
Xcel Energy / Black Hills Energy
Regulated Monopoly Utility
Consolidated Edison (ConEd)
Deregulated REP Market
♨️ Natural Gas Rate ($/Therm) $1.02 / Therm $1.65 / Therm
Natural Gas Fixed Customer Charge $18.00/mo $28.00/mo
💧 Water Base Meter Charge (5/8" - 3/4") $15.00/mo $14.50/mo
Water Tier 1 Volumetric (per 1,000 gal) $3.05 $4.45
Water Tier 2 Conservation (per 1,000 gal) $4.70 $4.45
Wastewater / Sewer Rates Base: $21.00/mo
Volumetric: $5.80/1k gal 		Base: $23.00/mo
Volumetric: $7.08/1k gal
🗑️ Curbside Solid Waste & Recycling $23.00/mo $0.00/mo
Stormwater Drainage Clean Water Fee $4.00/mo $0.00/mo
Initial Move-in Deposit / Connection Fee Deposit: $130 – $230
Turn-on: $20.00 		Deposit: $200 – $400
Turn-on: $30.00

Climate & Seasonal HVAC Load Drivers

NOAA degree-day data dictating peak air conditioning and heating power spikes.

NOAA 1991–2020 Normals
Climate Indicator Brookings, SD New York City, NY
☀️ Cooling Degree Days (CDD) 1,295 CDD 1,180 CDD
❄️ Heating Degree Days (HDD) 5,446 HDD 4,750 HDD
Peak Summer AC Bill Volatility +35% Summer Spike +42% Summer Spike
Regional Climate Summary NOAA 1991-2020 climate averages document 1,295 Cooling Degree Days and 5,446 Heating Degree Days annually across Brookings County. Dense urban heat island effect with high delivery tariffs and strict municipal regulations.

Clean Energy & Solar Economics

Rooftop solar irradiance and net metering rules to mitigate high utility bills.

NREL Solar Data
Solar Component Brookings, SD New York City, NY
☀️ Daily Peak Sun Hours 4.2 hrs/day 4.5 hrs/day
Net Metering / Export Compensation SD PUC net metering up to 100 kW with annual reconciliation at avoided cost. NYSERDA NY-Sun Rebate + NY PSC Value of Distributed Energy Resources (VDER) & 1:1 net metering.
City Solar Calculator Brookings Solar Estimator → New York City Solar Estimator →
🏙️ Brookings Official Estimator

Brookings, SD Utility Calculator

Access the interactive multi-utility calculator, municipal moving checklists, and verified billing schedules for Brookings.

ZIP: brookings Open Brookings Hub →
🏙️ New York City Official Estimator

New York City, NY Utility Calculator

Access the interactive multi-utility calculator, municipal moving checklists, and verified billing schedules for New York City.

ZIP: new-york-city Open New York City Hub →
Common Inquiries

Frequently Asked Questions: Brookings vs New York City

Direct answers to key cost of living and utility comparison questions.

Is it cheaper to live in Brookings or New York City for utilities? ▼
Brookings, SD is approximately 33% cheaper than New York City, NY in overall monthly utility bills ($293/mo vs $440/mo). A typical household saves around $147 per month or $1,766 annually.
How do residential electric rates compare per kilowatt-hour? ▼
Residential electricity in Brookings costs $0.124 per kWh supplied by Xcel Energy / Black Hills Energy, compared to $0.265 per kWh in New York City served by Consolidated Edison (ConEd). For a home consuming 1,000 kWh per month, this rate difference accounts for $141.00 in monthly energy charges before fixed customer meter charges.
What is the water and sewer rate difference between Brookings and New York City? ▼
In Brookings, the minimum fixed water meter charge is $15.00/mo plus $21.00/mo sewer baseline. In New York City, the base water fee is $14.50/mo with $23.00/mo sewer baseline. Volumetric Tier 1 water is $3.05/1k gal in Brookings versus $4.45/1k gal in New York City.
How does weather and climate impact summer and winter power bills? ▼
Brookings logs 1,295 Cooling Degree Days with a 35% summer AC bill surge. Conversely, New York City records 1,180 CDD with a 42% summer surge. Heating Degree Days measure 5,446 in Brookings versus 4,750 in New York City.
Related Metro Comparisons

Explore Other City Comparisons

Compare Brookings or New York City against neighboring cities and prominent US metro destinations.

📍 Popular Comparisons for Brookings

Brookings vs Sioux Falls, SD $293 vs $298 → Brookings vs Rapid City, SD $293 vs $293 → Brookings vs New York, NY $293 vs $439 → Brookings vs Los Angeles, CA $293 vs $395 →

📍 Popular Comparisons for New York City

New York City vs New York, NY $440 vs $439 → New York City vs Brooklyn, NY $440 vs $439 → New York City vs Los Angeles, CA $440 vs $395 → New York City vs Chicago, IL $440 vs $365 →
🏛️

Official Municipal Filings

Tariff data is sourced directly from city council utility rate resolutions, Public Utility Commission (PUC) filings, and retail provider dockets.

⚡

Federal Energy Benchmarks

U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) Form EIA-861M residential sales data is leveraged to calibrate regional seasonal consumption models.

💧

USGS & NOAA Climate Standards

Water and sewer discharge volume models use USGS per capita metrics; HVAC load draws from NOAA Cooling & Heating Degree Day (CDD/HDD) indexes.

⚡
Est. Monthly Bill
$335/mo